[DJScias]

Hello there,

To be honest I actually wasn't aware of that you had to give consent to people. As I've had some of my chars get hurt before and I just went with it because that's RP and I've gotten some pretty good after-effect RP out of it as well.

In my own opinion, I feel that you should only need a GM if both parties can't agree on a fight that would cause a possible death to one party. But I feel like injuries, how major they may be, should be allowed as is. We don't love in a huggy world and we have Guards and other people (see white knights) around to stop it.

The fact that this world is so magical, even if you were to lose a limb or perhaps a part of your body, there's means to stay alive here, perhaps even get better through the use of some clever inventions.

GMs have other things to look at and just being around for every sort of thing to say "yes or no" is going to become a drag, both for the playerbase and them. Your draft is interesting in itself though, but I feel that both 1 and 2 should be acceptable as is.

Number 3 is where I may agree that you'll need GM permissions (read above with possible char death). If at any time a person's char turns into a direction where death is inevitable both parties should discuss this between themselves. If they can't come to an agreement, THEN a GM should be called.

Of course, this is all my own opinion. I've always been a big fighter for things like "perma-death" and "actions equal consequences" in about every platform I've RP'd on.

Good post regardless, I hope having hear different people's opinions on the matter will help for us to get to some sort of decision.

Kind regards,
DJScias