[Ranylyn]

I think the 100% + 70% SWA isn't AS crazy as it looks, honestly. Say your SWA is 100 and you have 40 skill/Will, for ease of math. 120% SWA is 120, and 100%+70% of Ice attack comes up to closer to 135 (rounding; it's late and I'm lazy.) It's not especially drastic, and Cyclone Spear also has the benefit of re-positioning enemies. The main reason it's so strong is because a Duelist will be built for Skill regardless; they want to hit with basics, and Crystal Rose is primarily for AoE/Utility. Point being, I think lowering the ice attack a bit (maybe 50%) would be more than enough.

If the issues people have lie primarily with the Elemental effects (since some have said they're fine with the base skill and the issue is primarily with Blazing/Swift) the Elemental Impact could be given the Arrow Treatment: "If enchanted with ____." A badge wouldn't be good enough; they'd need to have the actual spell cast on them.