[Rendar]

Elemental Impact has a number of effects upon soldier weapons. However, a few do not interact well with charging strike.

The stats are as follows
34 power battlepick (100% str scaling)
40 strength
Martial Lawbreaker (Demon Hunter)
Rank 5 in all skills tested
Rank 5 Charging Strike
Rank 3 Charge
Rank 5 Axe Expertise
Elemental badges didn't self enchant.
Enemies had 3 DEF each

I will list each skill, and have the normal effects and the elemental impact effects put underneath a spoiler. I will also bold the effects that are outright bugged.


Shinken

Shinken (7 range) 152
---Charged (7 range) 152

Fire Fire Trail 152 (5 fire damage per cinder)
---152 (5 fire damage per cinder)
Earth Seeking (earth Damage) 152
--- 152
Ice Ice trails Ice damage 152
--- 152
Wind Wider attack, pushes back 152
--- 152
Lightning Forked Shinken 152 (crit did 178)
--- 152 (crit did 178)

Bug; it seems the shinken projectile is not benefiting from the +25 damage that charging strike is giving.

Roundtrip

Roundtrip 73/73
---Charged 85/85 MOAR RANGE
Fire Fire trail 73/73 (10 fire damage per cinder)
--- Fire Trail 85/85 (10 fire damage per cinder)
Earth HUGE PULL 73/73
--- MORE RANGE 85/85
Ice Ice trail 73/73
--- MOAR RANGE 85/85
Wind Extra range 36/36 ????????? (2nd test had it do 73/73. There is a bug with martial lawbreaker maybe?))
--- MOAR RANGE 85/85
Lightning Crit 73/73 (crit did 91/91?)
--- MOAR RANGE 85/85 (crit did 106/106?)

Bug; This is a mostly alright setting, however ther was an issue with the wind enchantment causing it to do 36/36, then next test do 73/73. Odd. Might be an issue with Martial Law Breaker, I got this a few times on the main server whenever I was testing shinken with a bow, it would occasionally bug out and do less. Can't get it to repeat on command, so something is off.

Thousand Stab

1000 Stab 22 per it seems like
---Charged 28 per it seems like
Fire 22 per hit (5 fire)
--- 28 per hit (5 fire)
Earth 22 per hit (5 earth)
--- 28 per hit (5 earth)
Ice 22 per hit (5 ice)
--- 28 per hit (5 ice)
Wind 22 per hit (5 wind)
--- 28 per hit (5 wind)
Lightning 22 per hit (5 lightning) (cannot crit?)
--- 28 per hit (5 lightning) (cannot crit?)

Bug; This is mostly alright. However I couldn't get the lightning version of it to crit. Is this a bug or intentional?

Incise

Incise 68
---Charged 93
Fire Level 10 burn, 68
--- Level 12 burn, 93
Earth Level 10 Magnetized 68
--- Level 12? 93
Ice Level 5 Celsius, 68
--- level 6 Celsius, 93
Wind Level 10 poison, 68
--- Level 12 poison, 93
Lightning Level 10 interference, 68 (cannot crit?)
--- Level 12 interference, 93 (cannot crit? Might have just been unlucky, tested 8 times)

Bug; This is mostly alright. However I couldn't get the lightning version of it to crit. Is this a bug or intentional?

Retreating Swipe

Retreating Swipe 157
---Charged (more jumpback) 181
Fire (Fire tiles in targetted location) 157 (5 fire damage per cinder)
--- (more jumpback) (Fire tiles in targetted location) 181 (5 fire damage per cinder)
Earth 166
--- (more jumpback) 166
Ice (ice tiles in targetted location) 157
--- (more jumpback) (ice tiles in targetted location) 181
Wind (more jumpback) 157
--- (even more jumpback) 181
Lightning (can crit) 157 (crit did 195?)
--- (more jumpback) (can crit) 181 (crit did 226?)

Bug 1: Galren Enchant does not seem to actually give extra damage upon a charging strike, making it deal extraordinarily lower damage in comparison. Could be that the bonus to power that it gets from rank is overwriting the bonus to power charging strike gives.

Sorry if it was a bit longwinded, I tested all of these out rather thoroughly. Thank you for your time.

[Neus]

Shinken; Projectile doesn't receive bonus damage from charging strike, only the attack.
Roundtrip; Combination Fighter maybe?
Thousand Stab; Doesn't lightning critical, only deals elemental damage.
Incise; Doesn't lightning critical, can inflict status effects based on enchant type.
Retreating Swipe; This was bugged and Galren was overwriting the bonus damage from other sources.

[Rendar]

I was Demon Hunter/Grand Summoner for the purposes of this test. Combination Fighter shouldn't have been applying whatsoever. Thanks though.

[Neus]

Combination Fighter is a Demon Hunter skill, so...

[Rendar]

Oh right. I was thinking of the MA one that gives +15% damage.

I am 100% certain I hadn't used any other demon hunter skills, considering if I had the jammer would have been dead.

[Neus]

Well, just post what it is if you ever manage to recreate it consistently.