[Kameron8]

I don't want my normal weapons to become switch-on-metagame weapons

(Not that I would metagame, but still.)

Then I'm not sure what the issue is. Having the opportunity to metagame enchant choices -- which already happens -- seems like a poor way to balance things. I'd think having your 'normal weapons' all being holy is about the situation I mentioned at the beginning of the post. It seems silly, to me at least, that EVERYONE wields zombie slaying weapons for no good reason except 'this might just automatically win me the fight sometimes'.