[Joseph Jostar]

All of the mage spells that have bonus effects that say 'if you're enchanted with Talvyd', etc, require the status to be active. It's not really inconsistent.

The unclear part is the badge text claiming that it 'treats you as enchanted with X for elemental impacts". Probably the simplest solution would just be to change that text to something like "will trigger ELEMENT elemental impacts for certain skills" and give elemental impact skills two variations of the impact icon in their skill description, one describing it as an elemental impact skill, and one clarifying it as an enchant-only impact.