[Lonestar]

I mean, if the perps are just oocly robbing you like little shits and don't even respect you trying to fight them/arrest them, ban hammer.

Yes, it's how should be and how it went. However, this suggestion is to prevent this from happening again.
Plus, if they're OOCly robbing you, there's no 'fight them/arrest them'. It's OOC for a motive.