[Kameron8]

I don't personally think it should be able to trigger a Weak message, given how trivial it is to apply the debuff. Weak roughly translates to a 50% damage increase, assuming it gives a player one extra spell to cast, and 100% damage increase for Youkai. Given that it already gives a -30% resistance before that consideration, the item as a whole is just busted when you hash out the numbers.

Players don't need to build offensively to use it, since water is Vit scaling. I'd rather just see the debuff incapable of generating weakness, but if it's non-negotiable, at least wall the higher percent behind a requirement to crit with the sword.