[Autumn]

I don't want to explicitly offer solutions to issue, and the in-depth explanation as to why the enchantment is strictly unfair is already explained in the OP, I do want to express that I support that enchantment should be touched upon in some way. Thus far my favorite solution was to have the damage reflect be related to guard LV (Damage cap = guard LV) so it stays useful in the right scenarios.

However it may go down I am fine with the outcome, it makes me disappointed that a shield specific enchantment has garnered this reputation, I do wish that it helped tanks prevent damage to their team like through reflecting projectiles or how not, allowing them to serve as a wall.