[Autumn]

You're wrong about it being good but I definitely understand not wanting to put even more points past your soft cap of skill to not get rolled by the one person who manages to have a 90% dodge chance at the cost of having below 700 HP and no defenses.

You're free to disagree, when evade works, it is absolutely very very strong. The summary you have put forth isn't how evade builds generally build (most I see go for substantial HP values), evade builds are incredibly volatile, some classes just do not get the hit to deal with you, and some do, which makes evade strong into certain matchups, and horrible into others.

They sometimes find ways to stay a bit more defensive too, and with the way DRs work in this game, a parry or substantial DR can go a long way for them, again though, very contextual to exactly what you're running, which cannot be covered by generalization.