[Autumn]

But the whole point of chaos dice is getting that one dream turn where you resist ice against verglas or something. It being announced means they can just physical attacks or another element, making it nearly pointless. Making your enemy waste an attack at an unexpected time is fair imo. Just think of spirit mirror's power level...

No not really, you hitting a 100% ice resistance perk randomly doesn't change the fact that you're immune to icicle spear's damage that turn, the enemy knows that and can change their strategy but now you don't have to worry about it that round.

But randomly rolling slash resist as a high roll into a sword duelist would be such a crazy momentum shift in your favor there'd be no reason not to run the item.