[Clockworkers Doll]

5. Are we supposed to make them sit with their thumbs up their asses when everyone else is hogging whatever beasts spawn?

Honestly, this suggestion is nothing more than pure salt to players that have their characters try to limit the damage while it's happening, for the sole reason of 'HOW DARE YOU TOUCH MUH EXP'. It is not impossible for something along the lines of 'we'll hold them off while you try to keep everything from falling apart' to happen, especially when some characters aren't even intended to be combatants. I see no reason to force them into a 'you must fight to do anything' requirement, and considering the EXP bonus at the end of the raid, someone cleaning up a few scars mid-raid is no real detriment.
Nothing about this suggestion should be implemented. Ever.

I was gonna stay out of the saltfest to keep myself safe but uh. That's really really funny. Like damn, you think Franky is salty, but ya' get all triggered like this?
-
On a less-salty note, I think Ranylyn has some good counter-points on the entire thing without sounding this way. I myself feel pretty neutral since I almost never do black beasts and I only do scars when my party leader is walking by, goes "ooo scar" and goes for it. Some people who're less comfortable with fighting can do scars, sure, but there's still a good chance of being buttfucked by a sudden BB spawn anyways, which seems like punishment enough imo. I think the best way, personally to get around the whole "b-but I'm not a fighter" is to sit and wait for the end (because let me tell you nobody will finish cleaning scars by the time it's over and you'll get something at least) or pseudo-team with someone else so they can defend you from the spawns while you clean and they attract that attention, which is more of a win-win without them leading you down and making you slow. And it's not like there isn't a few other ways to earn EXP non-combativly. We could use a few more probably, yeah sure, but still, it's just that scars seem to be the only constant and the easiest, which is dumb imo.
Maybe just make BB spawn rates higher so people aren't "sitting with their thumbs up their asses", eh Chaos?