[EenKogNeeto]

I'm going to echo the words of Balthie: Please read and refute the words by Trex. You have glossed over that post and it has been more compelling - and yet you've just kind of

...not even acknowleged it.
If you still want to believe this should be nerfed, show us why they're wrong and you're right.

I don't know what you want to be refuted. They agreed it was probably OP in PVE which is obvious.
Their points on PVP were in-depth, but also focused on Quickdraw itself rather than really this specific interaction with the guitar. And would be better ported to a thread talking about buffing QD. I'm not here to change the meta drastically by targeting Desperado or anything. I'm here talking about a very limited interaction that shouldn't exist due to balance concerns from massive amounts of unresistable damage.

Suggesting counters is irrelevant, I'm not asking how to counter it. I'm talking about how it's unbalanced if NOT countered specifically by any one member of the enemy team (Such as actually following your characters IC instead of stacking crit evade like the meta demands)

Guitar only being used because it interacts with guns as an offhand weapon is a silly reason to say it shouldn't be changed. Once it loses this interaction someone can make a post about buffing it if they want. It's perfectly fine on its OWN, I don't complain when someone jumps into the team and shreds a guitar on us with Circle swing or whatever the axe special attack is called. The issue is the ABNORMAL interaction with guns. Unless every weapon on that list up there turns out to proc it too, it's one of two weapons that do work fully on offhand.