[DoctorMad]

You're trying to argue that it should be nerfed despite being easily counterable because counters don't matter.(heck, you don't need a build dedicated to countering it, you just need a crit evade build in general, which is all purpose crit denial. Not having that will get you ripped to shreds by crits anyway).

By that logic, does everything need nerfing just because it can destroy people that don't have the capacity to deal with it?

No?

Well, neither does this. It's a simple thing. If you're not prepared for it, chances are you'll lose. This is a case of you not being prepared or Scissors meeting Rock and saying rock needs to become sponge instead because scissors can't beat it. The damage itself isn't even actually that remarkable either.

I do see the counterargument here, but it seems a bit disingenuous.

This isn't something you need to counter to survive better, this is something everyone in a team has to build for, otherwise they sabotage their teammates.
Its a pretty strong interaction for that reason.
Everyone in a team has to counter it, otherwise it slips by and starts damaging the rest of the team. Doesn't make sense to me.