[MothEnthusiast]

Ah, I didn't see the part where the whip thing was a Sweet Leaf exclusive at first. Sweet Smelling didn't click in my head when I skimmed over it, so that's my bad (I was thinking all whips had that trait inherently). I tested to make sure it applied to skills and spells, which it does. I guess that does make a difference, though I still would've personally liked if sweet leaf wasn't tied to whips. It'd be broken if ALL weapons didn't affect charms if you had sweet leaf, unfortunately.

As for the other scalings on health on whatnot, I wasn't really challenging the rest (though I realize now the post made it sort of seem that way). Even on the calculator, things like Shard hp weren't affected, so I don't really doubt there are exclusions. My point was just that your list wasn't 100% accurate.