[Slydria]

The point I was trying to make was that we shouldn't nerf Accelia too harshly so that it becomes an unviable option compared to the Weapons.

Kick is an autohit but Excel Weapons can inflict significantly more damage. (Yes, even with the 75% Scaling from Kick but I do agree that 75% is too much anyway.)

Math:

Let's just use your example stats. 60 STR vs 10 DEF (and 10 RES for convenience sake) and say the Excel Weapon has 15 Power.

STR+WPN Power+(Modifiers)*2.5-Enemy DEF (*1.5 with a Crit) + (Other Bonuses)

(60+15)*2.5-10 = 177.5 damage
(60+15)*2.5-10*1.5 =266.25 damage with a Crit

If we actually accounted for Modifiers. Let's say we are working with a Ghost with the works.

(60 + 15 + 7 from Elangrave + 14 with Power Gradation + 5 from Sword Expertise)*2.5 + 10 from Claret Call - 10 from Enemy DEF) (*1.5 from a Crit) + 10 Bonus Damage from Material.

(101*2.5)+10 = 262 damage
(101*2.5*1.5)+10 = 388 damage with a Crit


Compared to:

STR*3.25-Enemy DEF (75% with 3 Charges)
(60*3.25)-10 = 195 damage

STR*2.5-Enemy DEF (50% with 3 Charges)
(60*2.5)-10 = 140 damage

STR*1.90-Enemy DEF (30% with 3 Charges)
(60*1.9)-10 = 104 damage


Of course, all this neglects things like the target's Armor, Resistances, Skills, etc. so it's not really accurate, I just wanted to make a comparison.