[Rendar]

Yeah. -5 accuracy for +2-18 power is kind of silly. Make it either A) Scale with power, B) Make it give MOAR WEIGHT (makes archers better), or C) Something else we haven't thought of.

[Bjarn]

or you could reduce the scaling of the weapon a certain amount each bonus power it gets

say 1 or 2% from each scaling thing for each point of weapon power gained

[Lolzytripd]

Scaling isn't something you should mess with so strong handedly.


I prefer the idea of downsides to rebelling such as -hit or weight.

This still does nothing to remedy poor replica weapons.

Most multi scaling weapons fall into the

50/25/25(most 7* black book weapons), 50/50/50(best tomes ever), 40/40/40 (tessen daggers)

100% total, 150% total and 120% total respectively

Replica weapons are 60%/15%/15%, the main stat suffers heavily and the sub stats are so low they feel like they barely add to the weapon at all.

[Autumn]

Weight is not a downside anymore let's be honest, I'd prefer 1.5 power per rarity under 9, and a bigger accuracy debuff, that'd be a good place to start.

[Chaos]

As nice as the talk about Rebellion is, this really doesn't help the case of the Replica weapons at all. It's starting to feel like we're just dragging in barely/semi-related topics that cover up the OP at this point.

Lolzy's right in that Replica weapons are nowhere near as good as their rarity would suggest, nor even hold a candle to most of their competitors, due to wonky scalings. Adjusting the scalings might work, but I have a more specific idea in mind:

1. Set scalings to:
70% Main Stat
20% Sub Stat
10% SAN

2. Remove base Divine enchantment, then set base Durability to Unbreakable
(OPTIONAL: Increase weapon stats according to Divine's effects)

In other words, not only adjust the scalings a smidgen, but enable Replicas to be enchanted whilst retaining (some of the) properties of the Divine enchantment.

[Lolzytripd]

I happily back chaos's suggestion.
I can make do with anything with atleast 70% main stat scaling, I already subscribe to excel weapons 75% scaled attack lifestye.

[Snake]

I personally like Chaos' second suggestion. It'd make those weapons more unique, and heck damn, their icons are beautiful too, just saying. They could get more credit for the good looks.

[MegaBlues]

I would say that they should have a minimum total scaling of 120% or so. Normally, a weapon with three stats to scale off of would be much more powerful, but it comes with Divine for free, and Sanctity is a great stat. I would bump them up to 70% Main Stat, 30% Sub Stat, 20% Sanctity.

[Poptartu]

Could lower the number it takes into account for scaling by one or two, reducing the over all bonus of rebelling but not sticking on further penalties. You'd lose 2-4 power on every rebelled weapon.