Posts: 4,563
Threads: 733
Likes Received: 893 in 470 posts
Likes Given: 1,356
Joined: Sep 2015
Simple and short:
- Can the damage be changed to 5 + (5% of your Fist weapon's SWA) per Rank?
- Can this also trigger on Evasion? (The "within 1 range" already exists, so)
- And, if you have Mixed Martial Arts equipped, it changes the damage type and SWA used to your main weapon's?
And then for balance and bug reasons:
- Can the damage proc work like Flottement's movement? (i.e Only happens after all attacks are made, and only once. This is mostly to prevent multi-hit dodging/evading from scoring absurd damage numbers.)
- And this be changed to Evasive Reaction skill? (This shouldn't stack with Flottement and other On-Evade skills)
Reasons it needs a buff:
- This passive skill costs 5 Skill Points to be at least useful.
- On top of it, 1 Skill Slot to be equipped.
- The condition for it to trigger is already solid. "On Evade/Evasion", which requires a pretty high stat investment. Evade is an RNG thing, and so is the condition for this to trigger, so it might not cause any big balance problems. If not, the buff should be welcomed, imo.
- 10 damage is way too "pre-GR", when enemy HP pools ae likely between 800 HP. Also, to give it a more "Take this to your face" feel. 10 damage is a tap to the shoulder, damage wise, and often laughed at.
•
Posts: 987
Threads: 238
Likes Received: 59 in 41 posts
Likes Given: 13
Joined: Dec 2014
I support this change as even when I don't even PLAY this class, just a 10 damage bonus is sooooo pre GR.
OOC Devourer Of Souls: it makes me feel like someone slipped me acid laced water
•
Posts: 105
Threads: 16
Likes Received: 0 in 0 posts
Likes Given: 0
Joined: Apr 2016
You actually made us turn our heads to a skill that nobody (almost) bothers investing points in. And the way you just listed your cards..
As usual, Kunai. +1. =w=
~ ~
3 G
r e
d n
~ ~
•
Posts: 1,010
Threads: 280
Likes Received: 558 in 171 posts
Likes Given: 878
Joined: Nov 2014
I don't mind a buff to Evasive Strike. No one really uses it unless they have nothing better to invest in, so it probably wouldn't hurt to give it some love. Just because MA is still meta doesn't mean this skill should be left in the dust, in my honest opinion.
•
Posts: 187
Threads: 35
Likes Received: 23 in 13 posts
Likes Given: 24
Joined: May 2017
This skill always struck me as unimpressive, even when I didn’t know about the meta. I usually shun this skill because of how situational and pathetic it is.
But, at least you’ll be able to do something better if it does get buffed.
•
Posts: 985
Threads: 153
Likes Received: 25 in 4 posts
Likes Given: 1
Joined: Nov 2014
A damage buff perhaps, but this skill should not apply on Evasion.
[12:53:15 AM] Chaos: don't hit dyst
[12:53:18 AM] Chaos: that's cruelty to animals
[12:53:20 AM] Chaos: you have to shoot it
[12:53:20 AM] Dystopia: ye
•
Posts: 926
Threads: 281
Likes Received: 192 in 52 posts
Likes Given: 30
Joined: Apr 2015
"Chaos" Wrote:A damage buff perhaps, but this skill should not apply on Evasion.
Seconded on both points, Monk is an extremely powerful class with a huge set of tools already. While no skill should be godawful, it's important to keep an eye on context when making changes.
•
Posts: 498
Threads: 35
Likes Received: 0 in 0 posts
Likes Given: 0
Joined: Nov 2014
"Kameron8" Wrote:"Chaos" Wrote:A damage buff perhaps, but this skill should not apply on Evasion.
Seconded on both points, Monk is an extremely powerful class with a huge set of tools already. While no skill should be godawful, it's important to keep an eye on context when making changes.
i can finaly butt in without it being percieved as another "ma is sin" comment
Wholeheartedly agreed.
•
Posts: 4,563
Threads: 733
Likes Received: 893 in 470 posts
Likes Given: 1,356
Joined: Sep 2015
Not even if it's treated as Evasive Reaction skill so it doesn't stack with things like Void Assassin's Advancing Flow and Duelist's Flottement? What about it doing half the listed damage if proc'd on Evasion?
This skill being required 5 skill points and you being able to dodge is why I feel like it should get a broader utility, even if it's at half effectiveness.
It's not like a Monk can evade your classic Borneblood Kensei/BK hit stacker anyway. I can't really imagine big problems this could cause if the damage on Evasion got halved. It wouldn't be doing more than a speculated 20 damage before triggering your enemy's Evasion if their dodge is also high.
And even if it does proc on Evasion, people can just step away/knockback you and spam crystal rose, cinders, magic, hexes, shoot you and do anything beyond 1 tile from you, as they normally do when seeing you're trouble in melee range. (See: How to fight Boxers 101.)
And let's not forget Cobra Stance's Snake Dancer making you backflip away from melee range if Evasive Strike attempts to hit you, making it the hardest counter to this passive skill.
•
Posts: 1,049
Threads: 424
Likes Received: 466 in 146 posts
Likes Given: 307
Joined: Nov 2014
If it proc'd on Evasion you'd have MAs deleting people who dared use a multi-hit attack in one range.
As stated, it could use a slight damage buff to be worth slotting/investing in at all, but working with Evasion would make it far too powerful.
•