[Lolzytripd]

I've made this before but I wish to suggest it again, if only for the chance it be considered.

In regards to weapons of the same rarity designation as what a mutation seed would mutate into I suggest that odd numbers gain +1 and even -1

This is what it would result in

A 1 star dagger would become a fist
A 2 star fist would become a dagger
A 3 star sword would become an axe
A 4 star axe would become a sword
A 5 star spear would become a tome
A 6 star tome would become a spear
A 7 star bow would become a gun
A 8 star gun would become a bow

This would add more niche uses across the board to a number of weapons

[Shujin]

Please! its always a bummer to see a weapon mutate into the same weapon type.

[Autumn]

Should be stated what exactly this affects going forward.

Weapons this effects:

Dagger -> Becomes Fist weapon

Boxing Glove, Crashing Cymbals, Knuckleduster -> Become Daggers

Bloody Fang, Eresh, Fuuma, Moonblade, Nelten -> Become Axes

Graality, Spirit Axe -> Become Swords

Bamboo-bo, Cerron Scepter, Monk Priest's Staff, Pilfer Spear, Tuning Fork -> Become Tomes

Ampgeneoule, Blackmeteor, Chorusafhybyn, Devil's Tome (Scary if true), Excel Graph, Flamnyaghra, Fullurricane, Hymntaturych, Wellwegwet, Zerorewuin -> Become Spears

Fortune's Favor, Magical Meteor -> Become Guns

Blaster Trumpet, Tarnell -> Become bows

[Poruku]

Hell yeah let's go

[Lolzytripd]

Should be stated what exactly this affects going forward.

Weapons this effects:

Dagger -> Becomes Fist weapon

Boxing Glove, Crashing Cymbals, Knuckleduster -> Become Daggers

Bloody Fang, Eresh, Fuuma, Moonblade, Nelten -> Become Axes

Graality, Spirit Axe -> Become Swords

Bamboo-bo, Cerron Scepter, Monk Priest's Staff, Pilfer Spear, Tuning Fork -> Become Tomes

Ampgeneoule, Blackmeteor, Chorusafhybyn, Devil's Tome (Scary if true), Excel Graph, Flamnyaghra, Fullurricane, Hymntaturych, Wellwegwet, Zerorewuin -> Become Spears

Fortune's Favor, Magical Meteor -> Become Guns

Blaster Trumpet, Tarnell -> Become bows

none of it is really Oh gatcha in terms of breaking things compared to the mutato that already exists

what I'm personally interested in is Fuuma as an axe, Excelgraph as a spear, fortune's favor as a gun, and blaster trumpet as a bow.

[Miller]

Devil's Tome as a spear? That sounds extremely cool.

I don't really see any issue with this, mutation is a cool enchant and adds a lot to build variety so having more is never a bad thing.

[sadbot]

I think it's worth noting that, while this is not the case for all weapons that mutate into their own weapon type, many weapons are that star level specifically because being able to mutate them into anything else would be incredibly powerful.

[Lolzytripd]

I think it's worth noting that, while this is not the case for all weapons that mutate into their own weapon type, many weapons are that star level specifically because being able to mutate them into anything else would be incredibly powerful.

we have the full list there I don't see any standouts that would be all that scary as an alternative weapon.

Atleast nothing scarier than kiss farewell.

[Snake]

I mean, yeah. Not like WIL being used for spears is news, given the staves.

[renowner]

I'd love this. And I really don't think devil's tome being swapped to a spear matters at all.
All the spear skills still wont' be doing hellfire damage.
And you could already just demon hunter hellfire tome for that kind of effect anyway, with a better enchantment.