[Ray2064]

You can't add this to the game while excel parashu exists. It would become ridiculously dominant.

In my opinion there is no need for this. Instead I would suggest that base crit damage become 120 or 125 across the board instead of 110. This would mean you can actually play crit with any weapon, but guile will still be superior in crit damage. Axes will take a hit but they're still going to be the best strength critters.

In the end you can't look at a stat in a vaccum. Strength is more than the sum of its parts, because you have to factor in gear, classes, racials, and what builds use strength and how they would be affected. You have to consider two-hand, you have to consider fleur, etc. I think there's no need to add this to strength, it's something that was brought up before but it's just not necessary and it would also dilute the differences between the different stats.

I would rather have guile get other stuff than just crit damage instead tbh

I feel like Guile already has way enough as is, especially when you account for the fact it's a stat that weapons scale from and typically make use out of really well

Once again, this isn't about critical damage, but mostly getting your entire character  denied the moment someone decided to invest some points in FAI and get the funny Boner enchant